A Comprehensive Strategy: Afghanistan Force Requirements

September 21, 2009
Kimberly Kagan, Frederick W. Kagan

From the Authors

"President Obama identified a number of questions that must be answered before he can make a considered decision about whether or not to increase troop levels in Afghanistan. The assessment of General Stanley McChrystal, which appeared in the Washington Post on Monday, answers those questions. The assessment does not provide an estimate of the forces actually required, which were to be submitted in a later document.

The American people need to have a detailed explanation as soon as possible of what forces are needed, how they might be used, and why there is no alternative to pursuing the counter-insurgency strategy that General McChrystal proposes if we are to achieve the fundamental objectives President Obama announced in his March 27 speech, '…to disrupt, dismantle and defeat al Qaeda in Pakistan and Afghanistan, and to prevent their return to either country in the future.'

To inform the national discussion, therefore, we have produced a report that argues for an addition of 40,000-45,000 US troops in 2010 to the 68,000 American forces that will be there by the end of this year. The report illustrates where US, NATO, and Afghan forces are now and where additional forces are needed to accomplish the mission. It links the US force requirements to the growth of the Afghan National Security Forces on an accelerated timeline. It explains the methodology for assessing the adequacy of a proposed force-level. This product, and our recommendations and assessments, are entirely our own—they do not necessarily reflect the views of General McChrystal or anyone else." - Fred and Kim Kagan

Download the PDF Version

Download the PowerPoint Version

from http://www.understandingwar.org/press-media/commentary/afghanistan-force-requirements

also http://roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/21/fending-off-failure-in-afghanistan/#kagan

and How Not to Defeat al Qaeda
To win in Afghanistan requires troops on the ground. More analysis by Fred and Kim Kagan.
http://www.understandingwar.org/otherwork/how-not-defeat-al-qaeda

"No Alternative"-Guest Blog @ New York Times
http://www.understandingwar.org/otherwork/kagans-guest-bloggers-new-york-times
September 22, 2009
Megan Ortagus
ISW [Institute for the Study of War] President Kimberly Kagan and American Enterprise Institute's Director of Critical Threats Project Fred Kagan present their comprehensive strategy for success in Afghanistan.

Further, see

Order of Battle - Combat Forces in Afghanistan
http://www.understandingwar.org/files/AfghanistanORBAT.pdf

For more and continuing Afghanistan dicussions, also see How to Stop the Islamic Jihad
http://howtostoptheislamicjihad.blogspot.com/

How Not to Defeat al Qaeda
To win in Afghanistan requires troops on the ground.
http://howtostoptheislamicjihad.blogspot.com/2009/09/how-not-to-defeat-al-qaeda.html